Easter egg hunts are one of the most exciting parts of Easter celebrations for kids. Whether you’re organising a backyard hunt, a classroom activity, or a community Easter event, the thrill of finding hidden eggs is what makes the day so memorable.
While chocolate eggs are traditional, many parents and teachers now prefer mixing in non-chocolate prizes. Not only does this reduce sugar overload, it also gives kids something fun they can keep long after the hunt is over.
In this guide, we’ll explore some of the best Easter egg hunt prizes that aren’t chocolate. These ideas work beautifully for Easter parties, school celebrations, and neighbourhood egg hunts.
For more seasonal inspiration, explore our collection of Easter party ideas including games, decorations, and party bag fillers.
Disclosure: This post on party favours contains an affiliate link, and at no additional cost to you, I’ll earn a small commission if you decide to purchase after clicking through the link. I’ll only ever recommend things that I love and believe will help you, and the decision to purchase is entirely yours!
Small Toys
Small toys are one of the most popular Easter egg hunt prizes because they fit easily inside plastic eggs or small prize bags. They’re exciting for kids to discover and provide something fun to play with after the hunt.
Great small toy prize ideas include:
These small surprises are perfect for hiding inside eggs and make the hunt feel more rewarding. If you’re planning party bags after the hunt, many of these items also work well as party favours.
Craft Kits
Craft prizes are a fantastic alternative to sweets because they encourage creativity and keep kids entertained after the excitement of the egg hunt.
Simple Easter craft prize ideas include:
Craft prizes are especially popular for classroom Easter hunts because they provide a fun activity that children can enjoy later at home.
Bunny Plush Toys
Soft bunny toys are a classic Easter prize that children absolutely love. Even a small plush bunny can feel like a special reward for finding a golden egg or completing the hunt.
Ideas include:
These prizes work particularly well as grand prizes or special golden egg rewards during the hunt.
Glow Eggs
Glow eggs add a magical twist to Easter egg hunts. Simply place glow sticks or small LED lights inside plastic eggs and hide them around the yard.
They are especially exciting for:
Evening Easter egg hunts
Glow-in-the-dark hunts
Indoor hunts with dim lighting
Kids love spotting glowing eggs in the garden, and the glowing toys themselves become fun prizes.
Mini Puzzles
Puzzles make excellent Easter egg hunt rewards because they’re small, educational, and entertaining.
Popular puzzle prize ideas include:
These items are compact enough to hide inside eggs and provide a quiet activity after the excitement of the hunt.
Tips for Planning an Easter Egg Hunt
If you’re organising an Easter egg hunt, a few simple tips can help make it run smoothly.
- Use colour-coded eggs for different age groups
- Hide easier eggs for toddlers and trickier ones for older kids
- Include a few special golden eggs with bigger prizes
- Mix chocolate eggs with toy prizes
Combining different types of prizes helps keep the hunt exciting and ensures every child goes home happy.
Easter egg hunts don’t have to revolve around chocolate. Adding small toys, craft kits, puzzles, and plush prizes makes the experience more varied and memorable for kids.
With a mix of surprises hidden inside eggs, children get the excitement of the hunt plus fun keepsakes to enjoy afterwards.
Looking for more Easter fun?
- Cricut DIY Easter Bunting
- Easter Egg Hunt Ideas for Kids: 20 Fun & Creative Hunts
- Cricut DIY Easter Wreath
- DIY Easter Egg Nests
- DIY Easter Teacher’s Gift
- Ultimate Guide to Easter Party Ideas for Kids (Decorations, Games & Egg Hunts)
- Cricut DIY Easter Pop-up Cards
- Easter Party Games for Kids
Need more tips when it comes to planning that next important occasion? Check out our DIY party planning checklist and get started today!
